GNOME Shell moving forward

Some news about GNOME 3 and GNOME Shell:

  • The minimize and maximize window decoration buttons are now removed. It is estimated that these buttons are not useful actually, and users should be using Alt-Tab, the dock or different workspaces to switch between different applications, and maximize windows by double clicking on the title bar. As this will also make the desktop more difficult to access, I guess this also means that there are no plans to re-implement desktop icons.
  • The problem with the ellipsis of long application names has been fixed by enlarging the icons in the application browser.
  • On the #gnome-shell IRC channel there was a discussion earlier today about the implementation of shutdown in GNOME Shell. Several developers were in favour of just suspending to RAM by default and not showing a real shut down button by default. After 30 minutes, the system would wake up again and suspend to disk. Several developers did not seem to care about the risks of waking up a laptop while it’s being transported in a bag. Or about the fact suspend is not working properly on all systems.

I am extremely disappointed by these three things. When writing my previous GNOME Shell article, I still had some hopes that things would improve for the better, but I am giving up all hope: the GNOME Shell in GNOME 3.0 will definitely not be something I will like to use. I think it is also unacceptable that such important, drastic changes are made just before or even after the UI freeze. I have the feeling that GNOME Shell is purely the work of a few developers and designers who made some radical changes without any feedback or testing by real end users. The user community seems to be completely forgotten in the GNOME 3.0 development process. As only a few distributions are shipping live CDs, which are often rather unstable and rarely have a completely up to date GNOME Shell, only a very small amount of users is actually able to test and give feedback.

What will I do now? Skip GNOME 3.0 and hope that GNOME 3.2 will be better, once developers have taken into account users reactions? But that means that I will not benefit for more than another 6 months of any improvements to many of my preferred applications. Or use GNOME 3.0 with the old GNOME Panels (but will that give back my desktop icons)? Or shall I finally switch to KDE? Time will tell.

Update: the changes I described here can be seen in screenshots on Webupd8.

One Reply to “GNOME Shell moving forward”

  1. In other words: “How dare you want to use your system the way you want to. That’s bad design. Instead, we’ll force you into a rutt and tell you to re-learn all your habbits, because we know what’s best.”

    That sounds mighty familiar…

Comments are closed.